Benni's talent for finding trouble surfaces in an unlikely place - her own church. While volunteering at First Baptist - helping Gramma Dove direct the children's musical - Benni finds the beaten body of the handyman. But Walt Adams' death isn't the only mystery in town. The valuable Aznar violin, a historic California Missions period piece, has been stolen. Despite warnings from her husband Gabe, the chief of police, Benni has no other choice but to step in to help solve the case.